Breed Specific Legislation

March 24, 2014


Breed Specific Legislation – or ‘BSL’ – is the practice of using laws to regulate and restrict dog ownership based solely on the physical appearance of someone’s dog. It stems from the belief that some dog breeds are simply “born bad,” and identifying those examples can be as easy as noting certain physical features. In areas where “pit bulls” are restricted, authorities seek out dogs with large heads, muscular bodies, short fur, etc. – regardless of their genetic make-up.

Throughout recent history, select breeds have been targeted this way and large groups of innocent animals have lost their lives, typically after a well-publicized bite incident stirs fear in a community. This reactionary approach to public safety is regarded by experts as a knee-jerk and highly ineffective treatment for tackling the multi-faceted nature of any community’s dog issues, but it continues to be the fall-back solution in select countries as well as towns and counties dotted around the U.S.

Unfairly known as violent killers, Pit Bulls have suffered from the stigma of negative media coverage that has led to city-wide bans across the country. This breed-specific legislation has torn pets away from families, and killed thousands of innocent dogs in cities like Denver, Miami, Cincinnati, and San Francisco.

Far from being considered a killing machine on legs, pit bulls seem to be an American favorite in the early half of the century — indeed, during World War I, the country itself is personified as a pit bull on army recruitment posters, and several pit bulls go on to become famous in the American military. Referring to an athlete as a pit bull is a very common sports metaphor through the 1930s, and it is meant as the highest compliment.

There is also a famous racehorse in the late 1930s named Pit Bull, as well as a number of pit bull stars of early motion pictures. Frequently, pit bulls are associated with children, as in the Our Gang comedies ‘ The Little Rascals’, as well as with Buster Brown, both in short films and as the corporate mascot for a shoe company. The famous RCA Victor image of a dog and a gramophone also featured a pit bull terrier.

Unfortunately, many pit bull owners are faced with a type of breed bias that comes in the form of insurance companies that will not cover their dogs under their homeowner’s insurance policies. However, contrary to popular belief, these insurance company restrictions, known as “blacklists,” do not only apply to pit bulls.

The following breeds are commonly blacklisted by insurance companies:

  • American Pit Bull Terriers
  • American Staffordshire Terriers
  • Bull Terriers
  • Wolf Hybrids
  • Akitas
  • Chow-Chows
  • Doberman Pinschers
  • Old English Bulldogs
  • Rottweilers
  • German Shepherds
  • Siberian Huskies
  • Alaskan Malamutes
  • Presa Canarios
  • Great Danes
  • Boxers
  • Saint Bernards
  • Mastiffs
  • Boerboels

In conclusion, I personally think any kind of discrimination is wrong. No matter what species, breed, gender ANYTHING! I have two pit bulls who have done no harm to anyone. They are extremely loyal and loving dogs. When someone sees a pit bull or any other “aggressive” breed they flinch. Why? Do you know this dog? Did it try to attack you? No. You just assume its mean because of what they look like. Just give them a chance and learn to love them. All you will get in return in unconditional love and kisses.

Author: Community Care College VA Student Christian Castillo-Simpson


Request Information or Enrollment


Monday – Thursday 7:30AM – 10:00PM

Friday – 7:30AM – 5:00PM

4242 South Sheridan Tulsa, OK 74145

Phone number: (918) 610-0027

Fax number: (918) 610-0029

Veterinary Assistant Program

 Any Comments, Opinions Or Suggestions Are Appreciated

14 thoughts on “Breed Specific Legislation”

  1. Very well said! As the mommy of two “vicious” Boxers, I have received comments from veterinary “professionals” that I should train the aggressiveness out of my dogs. Phooey. Both of them bark loudly and charge the door when someone knocks, but that’s the extent of their aggressive behavior. Both would probably knock down an intruder and drown him in slobber before they would actually bite someone!

  2. This is an awesome blog. I have had many pit bulls. Just because there are bad people in this world doesn’t mean the breed is bad. There where times that other breeds where classified terrifying. Pit bulls are very loyal, beautiful, lovable animals. People need to realize it’s not the breed it’s the owner. Hopefully this catches people’s attention. Great job guys.

  3. Finally!! Ive been waiting on a blog like this! Im so tired of people judging pits!! Every pit bull I have ever come in contact with has been the sweetest and most playful things ever! In fact when I went to Texas and got to my friend’s sister’s apartment her pit bull ran up to me wanting to cuddle and give kisses! People need to stop judging and give them a chance, thats all they want is that one chance to prove that all they want is love!!

  4. Awesome article Christian. I have to admit I was always afraid of Pit Bulls..but I love their look and after meeting them face to face in the class..I want one.. I am no longer I hope to own a couple and be another Ambassador for the breed as you are..Kudos. This blog was one worth waiting for.

  5. My mom was always scared of pits she was bound and determined not to own any however she had two in her house and they was great my kids could climb over them pull on their ears never once getting mad and snapping at them. Great blob !!

  6. What a great Blog. Way to go Christian. I was very impressed at how you put your blog together. It was very educational. I was especially surprised to see that list of the nicest dogs and see that pit bulls were number 2, second behind lab. Retrievers. I really hope that people will get involved and fight against any of the breed bans if they are presented in their area. Good job girl.

  7. As a mommy of a lab rott mix and a wolf rott boxer mix. And also a pit bull lover. I can’t stand people who judge a breed by the name not its personality.

  8. Christian inabsolutely love your blog!!! I have Heras so much about diferent breeds and I believe in giving chances to get to know because it’s the owner who has to do with the character and attitude of the dog.. It’s wrong for insurance to discriminate against those breeds.. It made me so mad that when I alp lied at an apartment I had to find somewhere else because of them not permitting Rosie as if she were a vicious husky